If you had invested in a five-year bank fixed deposit two years back, you will not be a happy man today. In the period since, banks have repeatedly hiked the interest rates for their FDs with a one percentage point hike in the last one-month or so.
Then there are new products such as SBI Platinum Account offering 9 per cent returns for a three-year tenure.
The minimum investment required is Rs 100,000 and the offer will be open till 31 March 2007. A unique feature of this FD is the 'put option' introduced for the first time in India. A put option gives the investors windows of time before the end of the tenure to exit.
In this case, the investor can exit after one year and two years getting annual interest rates of 8.25 per cent and 8.50 per cent respectively. Just in case you are turning green with envy at people investing in higher paying FDs, there is hope.
| Time to break your FD | ||||||
|
It pays to break your FD and reinvest the money in current FDs with higher rates. This might mean reinvesting in an FD of a different bank. The table illustrates how a person who had invested Rs 100,000 in a five-year FD of India's top banks in 2005 will gain from a mid-course correction if he breaks his FD and invests in a 8.25 per cent FD from SBI for the remaining 3 years. | ||||||
|
Bank |
5-yr FD |
2-yr FD |
Value of FD in 2010 at 2005 rate (Rs) |
FD proceeds on premature |
Value of encashed |
Gain in 2010 (Rs) |
|
ICICI |
5.75 |
5.5 |
133,036 |
110,448 |
141,108 |
8,072 |
|
SBI |
5.75 |
5.5 |
133,036 |
110,448 |
141,108 |
8,072 |
|
HDFC |
5.75 |
5.5 |
133,036 |
110,448 |
141,108 |
8,072 |
|
Citibank |
3.5 |
3.5 |
119,033 |
106,159 |
135,628 |
16,595 |
|
ABN AMRO |
5.6 |
5 |
132,056 |
109,362 |
139,720 |
7,664 |
| Assumptions: Values arrived after using On Premature encashment, penalty of 0.5 per cent applied quarterly compounding deposits in multiple of Re 1 | ||||||
It pays to make a break. Despite penal rates for premature encashment of lower earning fixed deposits, it makes sense to encash them and move on to higher paying fixed deposits. This can be exhibited through a numerical illustration (see Time to Break Your Fixed Deposit).
Let's assume that in 2005, you had invested in a five-year FD of any major bank that provided 5.6-5.75 per cent per annum. If you encash it today, you lose on an average, 0.5 per cent interest due to premature encashment. If you invest the proceeds in a three-year SBI FD, which provides 8.25 per cent per annum, you would earn much more than staying invested in the old FD.
| Fixed income menu | ||||||
|
What various fixed income options provide | ||||||
|
Options |
Duration (yrs) |
Pre-tax returns (% pa) |
Effective post-tax yield (% pa) |
Tax treatment | ||
|
Bank fixed deposist |
5 |
8.25 |
5.48 |
Without tax benefits | ||
|
Post ofice time deposits |
5 |
7.5 |
4.98 | |||
|
Fixed maturity plan (FMP)* |
15** |
9.15 |
Dividend option: 8.02 | |||
|
Bank fixed deposits (Section 80C) |
5 |
8 |
5.31 |
Tax benefit under Section 80C | ||
|
Public provident fund (PPF) |
15 |
8 |
10.69 | |||
|
National savings certificate (NSC) |
6 |
8 |
5.31 | |||
| All tax calculations for individuals @ 33.6 per cent *From LIC **In months | ||||||
Look before you leap. The rising FD rates come into perspective only when you take tax and inflation into account. Post-tax returns of all fixed income options except public provident fund, a 15-year option, and fixed maturity plans of mutual funds (which at the moment don't have tenures beyond 15 months) are providing sub-six per cent returns which don't beat inflation. So, before you invest or re-invest in a high-interest FD, you will do well to ask whether such an investment will really be worth the while.
With inputs from Sunil Dhawan, Outlook Money
